The Ultimate Guide to Choosing the Best Material for Plantation Shutters

Table of Contents

Plantation shutters are a popular window treatment option that can add style and functionality to any home. However, with so many materials, it can take time to determine the best fit for your needs. This guide will explore the pros and cons of each material option to help you make an informed decision.

Understand the Different Materials Available

Wood: Natural wood plantation shutters are typically made from solid hardwood, such as basswood, poplar, oak, cherry, maple, or mahogany. These woods are known for their durability, strength, and ability to hold finishes well.

Plantation Shutters Wholesale Manufacturers

Basswood is a popular choice for natural wood plantation shutters due to its lightweight nature, stability, and resistance to warping. It is also easy to work with, making it ideal for customizing shutters with various finishes and stains.

Poplar is another common wood species used for natural wood plantation shutters. It is denser and more rigid than basswood, providing more durability and resistance to denting or scratching.

Other woods, such as oak, cherry, and maple, are also used for natural wood plantation shutters, offering a range of textures and grain patterns to match different decor styles. Mahogany is a denser and more expensive wood species with a rich, dark finish and high durability.

The specific type of natural wood used for plantation shutters depends on the user’s appearance, durability, and cost preference.

Pros:

  • Classic and elegant look that adds warmth and character to any room.
  • It can be customized with various finishes and stains to match any decor.
  • Solid wood shutters are lighter, which can help with the operation.
  • It provides excellent insulation, helping to regulate temperature and reduce energy costs.
  • Durable and robust and can last for many years with proper maintenance.
  • Solid wood shutters are available in broader and taller panels without the additional support of divider rails.
  • Available in a range of wood species, such as oak, maple, cherry, and pine, offering a variety of natural textures and grain patterns.
  • It can be repaired or refinished if damaged or worn over time.
Plantation Shutters Manufaccturing

Cons:

  • Vulnerable to moisture and humidity, which can cause warping, cracking, or rotting, especially in high-humidity environments.
  • It can be expensive, depending on the wood species and customization options.
  • Requires periodic maintenance such as refinishing or repainting to maintain their appearance and protect them from wear and tear.
  • It can be heavy and difficult to install, especially for oversized windows or doors.

Vinyl: Vinyl plantation shutters are typically made from a synthetic material called polyvinyl chloride (PVC), a type of plastic. PVC is known for its durability, strength, and resistance to moisture, making it an ideal material for shutters.

Vinyl Plantation Shutters

Pros:

  • Waterproof and moisture-resistant, making them suitable for use in high-humidity environments, such as bathrooms and kitchens.
  • Easy to clean and maintain, requiring only occasional dusting or wiping with a damp cloth.
  • Resistant to fading, cracking, or warping from exposure to sunlight or heat.
  • Affordable, with a lower cost compared to natural wood shutters.

Cons:

  • It may not offer the same natural and warm appearance as wood shutters.
  • They are less durable than natural wood shutters and can be susceptible to damage from impact or strong winds.
  • They cannot be stained or painted to match specific decor styles.
  • It may not add as much value to a home as natural wood shutters.

Composite: Composite plantation shutters are typically made of engineered wood or medium-density fiberboard (MDF) covered with a polypropylene coating or a high-quality vinyl wrap. The wood and resin mixture creates a strong, durable, and moisture-resistant material, making it ideal for shutters.

wood vs composite shutters

Image of a composite wood vs. natural wood

Pros:

  • Moisture-resistant, making them suitable for high-humidity environments like bathrooms and kitchens.
  • Resistant to warping, fading, and cracking, which can be caused by exposure to sunlight or heat.
  • More affordable than natural wood shutters while still offering a similar appearance.
  • Durable and easy to maintain, requiring only occasional dusting or wiping with a damp cloth.

Cons:

  • It may not offer the same warmth and natural appearance as real wood shutters.
  • The material may not be as solid and long-lasting as natural wood shutters.
  • Composite shutters are not available in many colors. In addition, matching trim can be more complex or not exact.
  • Composite shutters are heavier than wood shutters. 
  • Composite shutters are more rigid than solid wood.

Faux wood: Faux wood plantation shutters are typically made from a composite material that combines PVC and a wood or MDF core. The core is covered with a PVC or vinyl coating that looks like natural wood.

Faux Wood Plantation Shutters

Fauxwood Plantation Shutters (wood or MDF core)

Pros:

  • Moisture-resistant, making them suitable for high-humidity environments like bathrooms and kitchens.
  • Resistant to warping, fading, and cracking, which can be caused by exposure to sunlight or heat.
  • More affordable than natural wood shutters while still offering a similar appearance.
  • Durable and easy to maintain, requiring only occasional dusting or wiping with a damp cloth.
  • Environmentally friendly as they do not require harvesting of natural wood.

Cons:

  • It may not offer the same warmth and natural appearance as real wood shutters.
  • The material may not be as solid and long-lasting as natural wood shutters.
  • Limited range of color options compared to wood shutters.

Consider Your Budget and Style Preferences

When considering your budget and style preferences for plantation shutters, here are some factors to keep in mind:

  1. Budget: Determine your budget range for purchasing and installing shutters. Remember that natural wood shutters are typically the most expensive option, while vinyl and faux ones are generally more affordable.
  2. Style preferences: Consider the style of your home and the look you want to achieve. Natural wood shutters offer a classic, warm look and can be painted or stained to match your decor. Vinyl and faux wood shutters are available in various colors and finishes to match your home’s style and decor.
  3. Durability: Consider the durability of the material you choose. Natural wood shutters are durable but may require more maintenance to prevent warping or cracking. Vinyl and faux wood shutters are more resistant to moisture, distortion, and fading and require less maintenance.
  4. Energy efficiency: Consider the energy efficiency of the shutters you choose. Shutters can help regulate the temperature in your home, reducing the need for heating and cooling. Natural wood shutters provide excellent insulation, while vinyl and faux wood shutters regulate temperature effectively.
  5. Location: Consider the location of the windows where the shutters will be installed. For high-moisture areas such as bathrooms or kitchens, vinyl or composite shutters may be a better choice than natural wood shutters.

By taking into account these factors, you can make an informed decision on the best material for your plantation shutters that fits both your budget and style preferences.

Evaluate the Durability and Maintenance Requirements

When considering durability and maintenance requirements for plantation shutters, here are some factors to keep in mind:

  1. Durability: Consider the durability of the material you choose. Natural wood shutters are durable but may require more maintenance to prevent warping or cracking. Vinyl and faux wood shutters are more resistant to moisture, distortion, and fading and require less maintenance.
  2. Maintenance: Consider the maintenance requirements of the material you choose. Natural wood shutters require regular cleaning and may need to be re-stained or painted over time. Vinyl and faux wood shutters are easy to clean and require minimal maintenance.
  3. Location: Consider the location of the windows where the shutters will be installed. For high-moisture areas such as bathrooms or kitchens, vinyl or composite shutters may be a better choice than natural wood shutters.
  4. Sun Exposure: Consider the amount of sun exposure your shutters will receive. If your shutters are exposed to direct sunlight for extended periods, choose a material that is less likely to fade or discolor over time.
  5. Climate: Consider the environment where you live. If you live in an area with high humidity or extreme temperature fluctuations, choose a more resistant material to moisture and temperature changes.
How-To-Care-for-Interior-Wood-Shutters

Considering these factors, you can choose the most durable and low-maintenance material for your plantation shutters that will stand up to the conditions in your home and require minimal upkeep over time.

Assess the Insulation and Energy Efficiency

When considering insulation and energy efficiency for plantation shutters, here are some factors to keep in mind:

  1. Material: The material of the shutters can impact their insulation and energy efficiency. Solid and composite wood shutters have better insulation properties than vinyl or faux wood shutters.
  2. Louver size: The size of the louver (the horizontal slats that make up the shutter) can impact its insulation and energy efficiency. Larger louvers allow more light and heat to enter the room, while smaller louvers provide better insulation.
  3. Frame type: The shutter’s frame can also impact insulation and energy efficiency. A structure that fits snugly against the window frame will provide better insulation and prevent air leaks.
  4. Installation: Proper installation is crucial for maximizing the insulation and energy efficiency of your plantation shutters. Ensure they are installed correctly without gaps or spaces between the shutter and the window frame.
  5. Location: Consider the location of the windows where the shutters will be installed. South-facing windows typically receive the most direct sunlight, so shutters on those windows may need to provide better insulation and energy efficiency.

Considering these factors, you can choose the most energy-efficient material and shutter design for your windows, ensuring your home stays comfortable and energy-efficient throughout the year.

Consult with a Professional for Expert Advice

While this guide can help you understand the pros and cons of each material option for plantation shutters, it’s always a good idea to consult a professional for expert advice. A professional can assess your needs and preferences and your home’s unique features to recommend the best material for your plantation shutters. They can also guide installation and maintenance to ensure your shutters last for years.

Ask For A Quick Quote

You may expect a response from us in 1 to 2 business days, please pay attention to the email with the suffix “@goodwoodshutters.com”